Update November 2021: I bought a second one; updated thoughts are at the bottom. Original review from late 2020: Ceiling fans are incredible for heat control. My home came with three different ceiling fans, and one of them - a Minka Aire Lightwave (around 54"?) - seemingly needed to run on medium or high speed to have any cooling effect. Building an Apple Homekit-enabled "smarthome" meant it was ripe for replacement with a HomeKit-enabled fan, for which Hunter is just about the only option, and the Romulus is only one of two choices that come with fan blades getting you to 60". I'll include some tips about my setup experience at the bottom of this review. Briefly, what I love about the fan: great airflow; nice technology integration; easy to set up (and I say that as someone who isn't overly handy, and who had never swapped out a ceiling fan before); nice appearance. 5/5 from me on these aspects. Using a ladder, a combo drill/driver to speed up inserting screws, a small pliers, and regular scissors (for cutting the wire to length and gently removing part of the wiring insulation), I was able to do the install in just a few hours. If I were to rate purely based on the letdowns it would be 3/5, to give a sense of how severe (or not) the issues are: 1) The LED light refresh rate is low. Go ahead and wave your hand in sunlight; now come indoors and repeat that in an area illuminated only with artificial lighting. If your hand's motion appears a bit choppy, you have lighting with a slower refresh rate. This isn't necessarily unexpected with dimmable lights, and may represent an unrealistic expectation on my part (I'm not an expert), but I had expected it to be flawless. 2) The remote control, while sleek, isn't overly useful. My other fans allow you to set the speed with a single button, and some even have timers. This fan remote has four buttons: light; fan; up; down. Granted, it's a "smart" fan and I only touched the remote when setting the fan up (I've done all of my other controls through HomeKit), but for the cost I would have expected more. 3) The fan blades looked and felt cheap up-close. They look fine when they're mounted, and from a practical standpoint it doesn't really matter (and it makes sense to have lighter blades), but be prepared for this if you're installing it yourself: they almost feel like they're made of foam, and the wooden print looks a bit sad when it's in your hand. 4) The light does not seem to come on even after power is cut to the fan. Pretty much all of my other fans will at least function like a light if you cut the power to them and then turn it back on, which is a useful thing. The Hunter fan seems to keep the light off if it was last in an off state, even if you cycle the power. Less of an issue given that it has more connectivity options, but it would be nice if this behavior were at least programmable. Maybe the most telling thing is that, if and when the time comes to replace the ceiling fans in my other rooms, I would definitely consider getting this same model as a replacement, and I would consider doing the installation myself again. I guess that's the best endorsement of the fan that there ultimately is: if I would buy it again, I can recommend it to others. Lastly, some tips for people who already bought the fan, or who may be having some questions about the setup: DO I NEED THE APP EVEN IF IM USING HOMEKIT? Yes, if you want to silence it or run a firmware update (my fan came already up to date), otherwise the app does not seem to offer any benefit. DIGITAL SETUP: Overall pretty easy, but not flawless. I had to repeat things twice: I added in HomeKit first, and the app threw an issue over it; I renamed the fan and that seemed to cause another issue in the app. Just set up through the app first, don’t rename anything during the initial setup, and it seems to be fine (or maybe everyone has to do it twice). I renamed the fan once it was set up and the app didn't have an issue. HOW DO I ENABLE DIMMING? Puzzling to me is the fact that the dimmable light seems like a major feature, yet out of the box the light is either off or on. This feature can't be enabled through the app. Website instructions aren’t 100% clear. Hold the up and down buttons on the remote at the same time (the entire button depresses) and it enables. I needed to cut power to the fan with my wall switch and then turn it back on for dimming to be recognized in the app and HomeKit. This was the only time I absolutely needed to use the remote for anything. HOW DO I DISABLE THE BEEP? Use the app, tap on the small “i” on fan speed, tap on “Features,” and there is a little toggle button for “Audio feedback.” Enjoy the silence! UPDATE November 2021: My original fan is working about the same as when I bought it - there are no issues with disconnects. Siri control is a bit temperamental, which is something that seemed to develop later; some devices can control the fan perfectly by voice, while others will report that they've changed the setting but nothing actually happens. Control via the Home app or widgets is always flawless, though, and I have not touched the remote since the initial setup. I liked it enough that during a brief price drop on the fans I bought a second one. Hunter has made some under-the-hood changes since the first one; the manual indicates a fan weight that is about two pounds less compared with my original. The setup process can now be completed entirely through the app and does not require the remote control at all. Firmware on the new fan indicates a very different version number, and it's unclear to me if this means that firmware updating is broken or if the underlying hardware on both fans uses different firmware versions. The way that the fan behaves in HomeKit is also a bit different. With the original fan, Homekit used a ceiling fan icon, and by default grouped the fan and light control together. Fan and light controls are still grouped by default with the newer version, but the fan icon is now a standard fan (which may be something on my own HomeKit setup; unfortunately it seems Apple may have removed the ability to easily change the icons). With the older model you could set the fan speed to any percentage and it would presumably choose one of the six speeds based on what was closest to the number you had set, but the newer fan will seemingly forcefully change the fan speed to the speed numbers in the Hunter app (which, confusingly, seem to go roughly by 16). This has led to some frustrating situations where you set a number below 16 (usually by accident), the toggle moves itself as if the fan is shut off, but the fan remains spinning. In this regard it feels as if there has been a regression in HomeKit performance, at least a little. That said, it still performs well and I value being able to control it through HomeKit. With further price drops I'd still buy more of them to replace some other ceiling fans that I own, but my conclusion remains the same as before: if there were another company making fans with flawless HomeKit support I wouldn't replace the Hunter fans with them, but I would use them to replace my current "dumb" fans instead.
