I used to use this stuff nightly to remove stubborn eye makeup, then one day I went into Ulta, and POOF, it was gone ????. I loved it so. I tried philosophy, but even at a much higher price tag, nothing compared. The question is, why did I believe the lady who told me it’s discontinued and NOT at least try Amazon until now? I’m virtually slapping myself in the face right now ???? . There they only had the smaller size for sale, too, but I literally mourned this stuff, finding it alive and well like two + years later on here. I feel so angry with myself, but relieved at the same time. I’ve personally never found better, and I’ve tried A LOT! I’ll never leave you again Mario! Omg.. I’m soooo happy, just mad at myself for not checking out what she said. I feel like buying more just in case this is too good to be true, but right now I have the bigger bottle in hand that I never had before, and could not be more thrilled! A little goes a long way. Even the smaller bottle, with daily use, lasted for some time. Even though it’s premium beauty, it’s really inexpensive for it ????. 5++++ stars! (If you love heavy eye makeup, too.. this works SO good! Of course, minimal eye makeup will be easy peasy for this product, but big jobs like me? This stuff ROCKS for!) I’m praying we never part ways again ????! ***Side note- Oh, and the consistency of the actual product is perfect. It’s not all runny or like water like some removers. No waste, and it is the perfect consistency to use gently but effectively.. getting the job done, and fast! Some are too runny and wasteful. Overall, less effective in my book. I have very oily skin too, so I’m happy I’m not left all oily either. See pics of consistency.*** ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️++++ I hope this review has been helpful, and if so.. let me know :).